Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by MrQuincle 3380 days ago
Moreover data is collected over the entire history. A matrix is a linear operator from time step T_i to T_i+1. By conflating all historical observations into one matrix it definitely is not an ordinary transition matrix.

That apart from the fact that it is questionable that it can be represented by an operator that is finite and linear.

It's more likely a stochastic process (infinite matrix) with births and deaths.

I would be surprised if it became true. :-)

1 comments

That was my immediate thought upon reading. A little more accuracy in the description would be helpful. This should be presented as: "If this aggregated data reflected a constant across time, then we can see where language usage would end up in the 'long run distribution'." But the jump matrix shown here will change with time. Most likely, if search results could be binned up by time period, the time dependence of the distribution represented by the eigenvector(s) would be somewhat interesting to watch, even if not remotely predictive. Could animate that or contour plot it.... exercise for the author... :)