Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by philliphaydon 3379 days ago
Why would you try drag it? Maybe I'm used to iOS I don't swipe those things I just touch them...
4 comments

Why wouldn't you? It looks like a slider toggle, not a checkbox.
what is a "slider toggle"? sliders should be used for ranges of values. checkbox for toggling values.

we could argue it's unfortunate that iOS(?) decided to start making their "checkboxes" look a little like sliders, but they still only toggle values thus you don't slide them.

in any case, i get where you're coming from. using mousedown instead of click or up maybe kind of solves both use cases?

"Checkboxes" that look like little sliders usually are good UI because they avoid this confusion, "is the control showing me the current state or the option to change to the desired state?" For whatever reason, toggle switches like this better convey that they're displaying the current state before you touch them.
The slide is so big on this one that it looks like multiple targets. The iOS ones are small enough that the only useful interaction is to mash with fingertip.

mousedown++ but also touch events

People do though, I often watch (and cringe as) my parents do it.
> Why would you try drag it?

Because it’s large and I want to see it wiggle? :D

I still intuitively (try to) slide toggles on my iPad. Just because Apple did it wrong doesn't mean everyone should adapt.
Which version of iOS? As far as I can tell you can tap or swipe/slide the switches.
I don't see a button, it has a background that suggests it'll slide when dragged.
yup same here, i still love it tough