Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thomasmarcelis 3379 days ago
It is mandatory for there to be a light at the intersection by law
1 comments

Yes, I get that. But it's a stupid law, and it should be changed. Traffic laws are not handed down by the gods.
Yes great idea. Build a new rule into a nation-wide law just to solve a problem that needs no solving as "red light with static green right arrow" is a typical sight over here in Germany and drivers DO understand it.

It would be much better to change traffic la nation-wide so we can get rid of this ONE traffic light in Germany. Isn't it?

Yes. It's stupid for a law to vest absolutely no discretion in the engineers so they may adapt to peculiar local situations.
Yes, that light is costing tax payers every year to operate it. The law should be changed so that there is no need to do this.
Changing the law and checking correct enforcement costs way more in people hours than the cost of operating a single traffic light. People underestimate the cost of regulation. Also, a consistent and simple set of rules should always be preferred and causes less human errors.
How much do you think it will cost to verify that such a legal change will not have unintended side effects?
Changing the law costs a lot, lot more you know..