Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mingyeow 3404 days ago
I am actually sincerely curious - is this considered a felony if proven? Seems like a major offense to steal such a massive amount of information blatantly for self enrichment, even if done under the missive of "changing the world"

This cannot end well.

3 comments

The suit is a civil tort, seeking damages. A felony is a criminal charge, usually against a person. I'm sure Google can call the CA District attorney and/or the western US district attorney to make a criminal complaint, State and Federal, respectively. I'm not an expert on the actual criminal charges available on each level but probably something about trade secrets if we're talking federal charges.

    git clone REPO_NAME
It really depends on the specifics of the case... the above could easily download 14K documents (necessary for doing work by said employee) a full 6 weeks before leaving the company.
Some info about criminal penalties under UTSA and DTSA here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_secret#United_States

I think that DTSA may not hold here because it wasn't signed until the events occurred.

I went looking into this after a comment from Animats in yesterday's thread struck me as odd

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13719070