Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hobofan 3401 days ago
I would really like to see a good tool in the "beyond Google Sheets"-space.

I tried Ragic just now for 10-15 minutes and it is far from simple, like their landing page claims. It is nothing at all like a database and it also is nothing at all like a spreadsheet (and not in a good way).

Edit: Looking at previous discussions about it here on HN, the criticism in this 5 year old comment all still holds true: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3960207

5 comments

Not sure what you mean by "beyond Google Sheets" space, but there have been some cool spreadsheet tools emerging recently.

http://www.alphasheets.com/ is still mostly in stealth (as far as I can tell) but they let you mix and match SQL, Python, R, and Excel formulae in a spreadsheet.

Airtable seems pretty polished (https://airtable.com/).

Both of these are definitely spreadsheets, though. Not sure if you're looking for something more specialized for a certain vertical or problem domain.

Founder of Airtable here--Airtable is actually a relational database with foreign key relationships (the technicalities of which are abstracted away from the user). It's designed specifically to be somewhere between the accessibility of a spreadsheet and the customizability/structure of a Filemaker/Access/Force.com, all with a much more modern UX and collaboration experience. Airtable.com/product or Airtable.com/templates offers some more context!
Thank you for Airtable, I'm a big fan, especially of the Zapier integration. Lately there has been a lot of discussion on Hacker News about projects like Opps Daily [1] and Nugget [2], where people write in about some pain point they have in their daily job that might be solved by custom-built software. I get the impression that Airtable + Zapier could solve a lot of those use cases.

-- [1] http://oppsdaily.com/ [2] https://nugget.one/daily

Thanks for the kind words! We love Zapier and use it extensively ourselves : ). Here's some example workflows Zapier wrote about: https://zapier.com/blog/airtable-automations/ https://zapier.com/blog/how-zapier-uses-airtable/
Ironically, we used Airtable + Zapier as our core backend when we launched Nugget... It worked great!
Airtable looks like exactly what the world needs for a modern system to let everyday users manage data well rather than bunging it all in a spreadsheet.

But the row limits are too low for many obvious uses. I assume this is for technical reasons? Otherwise it doesn't make much sense that if you pay for 20 users to share a database you get the same number of rows as if you pay for two.

Things that I would like to see in Airtable:

1) Being able to link tables in different bases https://community.airtable.com/t/link-to-other-base/107/112

2) Being able to create linked records from form view

Thanks for the feedback!
Quick feature requests:

1) Foreign keys to users (for e.g. "assigned to", "team members")

2) Better programmability - right now, anything moderately complex requires a bunch of intermediate column (that then have to be hidden from all views). Objective spreadsheets (MIT SAIL) seems like something to aim for.

3) Programmatic (API) access to row history - at least read, for reports

Thanks for all the feedback! These are all things that we're considering : ). In particular #1 is actually in private beta right now!
AirTable.com is a really great tool in this space - simple and works well
Fieldbook is also an alternative. https://fieldbook.com
Can anyone please suggest an OSS variant in this space? I would kill to use something like this, but for my use case has to be OSS.
So, applicable name then?