Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hrodriguez 3407 days ago
Click bait title with a touch of fear-mongering from another MSM outlet.

"as they searched for an undocumented immigrant who had received a deportation order to leave the United States."

"The search was conducted at the request of Immigration and Customs Enforcement"

Seems completely reasonable.

2 comments

I take a different view. I would expect the airline to know the full name and age and travel history of every single person on the flight from SFO->NYC.

Did they tell CBP that the person was on the flight? Did they tell CBP that the person may have been on the flight? Didn't they know for sure?

Don't we have computers now?

Why? What makes it reasonable to search all passengers on a plane to find an undocumented immigrant, that wouldn't also make it reasonable to search all passengers on a bus, or all congregants at a church, or all pedestrians at a crosswalk, or similar?

What happens if I don't have my citizenship papers with me? Is ICE going to take my word that I'm not the person they're looking for and I'm actually a citizen?

Why should I, a natural-born US citizen, be obligated to carry my citizenship papers around with me in any of those situations just in case ICE decides to show up? I have certain rights as a US citizen, and one of those is that I expect to be able to travel domestically without carrying my papers and without ICE detaining me.

That you're a natural-born citizen is completely irrelevant; naturalized citizens are no less entitled to the exact same rights less serving as POTUS. See the supreme court ruling from Luria v. United States, 231 U.S. 9 (1913). Link: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/231/9/case.html