Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by compuguy 3417 days ago
I still don't understand why they strip memory from machines from a classified setting. Once powered off, the data is only recoverable for a short time.
5 comments

Actually this might be evidence in favor of the claim that the NSA has fancy methods for RAM data recovery.
Just in case? If a technique was developed to get information off it tomorrow it would take months/years for department policy to catch up.

It could also be a hold over from when memory wasn't so volatile.

> Once powered off, the data is only recoverable for a short time

It comes down to defence-in-depth.

That short time is usually between seconds and minutes.

A can of compressed air can extend it a bit, but a dip in liquid nitrogen can turn the dial up a long way. Other techniques may appear in the future.

You need to trust that one of your own people won't do any tampering to extend the RAM. Much easier to verify there isn't any on the way out the door.

Why risk it?
Simple (and good policy). Defends against unknown attacks like additional circuits hidden in the ram and so on.