Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by drallison 3425 days ago
diogomonicapt writes "Light does not travel at the speed of light (no pun intended) because it is hard for it to do otherwise. No. It travels (and does so at that particular speed), because it is impossible for light to do otherwise."

Actually,the speed of light in a vacuum is an upper bound. The actual speed of light can be substantially slower. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_light

Some cosmological theories do not require the speed of light to be constant and fixed, and replace that axiom with requirements on the relationship of the speed of light with other physical parameters.

1 comments

He didn't say "the speed of light in a vacuum", he just said "the speed of light". And in the next sentence he said

> … it is simply not possible for light to be still, or even propagate at a different speed in the same medium.

So he's already acknowledged the fact that the speed of light depends on the medium. His point, though, is that light must still travel at this speed (even though the speed itself depends on the medium).

The speed of light in a medium is still the speed of light in vacuum if you look carefully enough. The apparent slowdown is just an emergent effect due to the interaction of photons and the particles making up the medium.