[GrinningFool]

Good! I'd like to talk about what the engineer learned from the experience. Certainly if trawling through someone's public repos and records turns up a pattern of repeated mistakes, that should be considered - but the mistakes we all make from time to time are chances to learn.

So what I'd be interested in seeing is if the candidate did learn. The mistake is less important than the candidate demonstrating they moved past it as a stronger developer.

On the flip side - given a choice in situation, I'd prefer not to work for a place that dredges up my old bugs and uses them in isolation as a basis for their decision. That suggests the kind of environment I wouldn't enjoy being in.