Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by danielsju6 3431 days ago
Being paid to take a photograph is different though. That's not speech, that's a professional service.
2 comments

The two aren't mutually exclusive. I imagine you would agree that a journalist still engages in protected speech when he writes articles in exchange for compensation. Why isn't a photographer also engaging in protected speech when he takes photos in exchange for compensation?
Are you saying that an act is no longer considered speech if you're paid for it? This seems to fly in the face of innumerable legal precedents, from porn to commissioned/sponsored art works to TV shows.
As it's engaging in commerce it is subject to regulation.