Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eevilspock 3425 days ago
RangerScience, many people, myself included, have. And guess what? We are down-voted. And then our future posts are automatically pro-actively ranked lower (A penalty has been attached to my account. See my history. Do I deserve that?). Politics is discouraged and even banned[1]. HN prides itself as being "a place for civil discussion", but it achieves that through effective suppression of dissent and criticism of SV culture. It's worked. I rarely comment here anymore.

[1] https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/05/hackernews-calls-for-polit...

1 comments

How are you distinguishing from suppression of dissent and criticism, and suppression of uncivil discussion?

From what I've seen, contrary opinions that are well expressed are rewarded (even if controversial - I've got a few that ultimately got more up votes than down, but it was a ride). Contrary opinions that, well, presume a fight? Not so much.