[WayneBro]

...in a perfect world.

I got some news for you: this world ain't perfect.

[j2kun]

In the actual world, though. This is why we don't perform lobotomies or think atoms are a plum pudding.

[WayneBro]

Incorrect. "Science" is the reason why we had things like lobotomies in the first place.

Your entire arguments rests on a "No true Scotsman"-like logical fallacy.

[j2kun]

I'll reiterate my point: science is not immune from mistakes (nobody is arguing that), but in general, it tends to correct those mistakes over time.

[WayneBro]

There is no science without people though...and people are not immune from mistakes.

[j2kun]

Nobody is saying they are, which is my entire point

[WayneBro]

No, that was my point. You were trying to say that it's OK because it correct itself over time. However, that fact does not really help us in the present time.