Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by colanderman 3435 days ago
No, because no-one wants a home AP that only works if it's pointed at you.

You can buy directional APs if you want, but they're usually used for outdoor point-to-point links, or as sector antennas. e.g. I just installed one of these today: https://routerboard.com/RBSXTG-2HnD in a place that needed a signal far from where the AP was. Usually patch antennas (like this product) are preferred over Yagis for microwave links due to their smaller footprint, and capability of dual polarization in a single package.

Better is if your indoor AP can transceive in more of a "pancake" shape, like this: https://routerboard.com/RBOmniTikU-5HnD Note that's almost the same gain as this home-grown Yagi (7.5 dBi vs. 8.5 dBi) but with a more useful directionality.

2 comments

Antenna gain is a function of directionality and vice versa. Patch antennas are also good because they have often very low "backward gain" but at the same time they are not very directional forward, so they are good to be placed in a corner of a room or near a wall.
It is illegal, according to another comment:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13459834

As I said in that comment, it's perfectly legal (and useful) so long as you turn down your TX power a bit.