Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by themodelplumber 3434 days ago
> frankly the introvert extrovert juxtaposition is trite at this point

Why? There's a huge amount of published research in the I/E scale in forms like the FFM. We have Ph.D.s on HN who are deeply involved in psychometrics and work with these models every day.

> But why can't extroverts be good at research and listening?

This is a much better point. They can.

The weird thing about this article is that the author uses a dichotomy like E/I, then seems to suggest that all customers dislike E salespeople. Or that, maybe, all E salespeople are the same type of person. That's simply not true.

> What if you're driven and enjoy a good balance of quiet time and social time?

This is also crucial, the question of personality type vs. personality type _development_.

2 comments

Trite doesn't mean inherently bad, it's just beaten to death on a very shallow level. If you were to list the most overused themes that hot takey bloggers use to build theses around, this is one of them. And it’s a shame because I’m sure there is a lot of new, interesting, and legitimate research being done on the subject. Unfortunately that research isn’t involved in a lot of these kinds of articles, for example this one.
Trite has an undeniable negative connotation. If you want to hedge the word, don't use the word. Further, you are saying this is bad...
Spot on. There is a real, measurable difference that scientists call extroverted or introverted. Then there's a bunch of stereotypical behaviors and attributes assigned to each. This article uses the latter.