[radley]

Ugh - did anyone take a look at his portfolio? He designs for video games so of course the specs are exaggerated.

He did something fun and most of HN is railing on him. The same criticisms ought to be said here - if you're going to criticize, first take a look at the whole picture and don't jump to conclusions.

[smhost]

I agree that the ad hominems are unfair, but bad design is bad design regardless of authorship.

[AznHisoka]

But part of me thinks he's an armchair product designer. Anyone can create a cool looking mockup. But what about the actual thing?

[adamlett]

Anyone, huh?