[ska]

   Why should a government be able to coerce a private organization into providing data? 

Perhaps when it is benefiting from public infrastructure in the activities that generate that data? Not sure where I come down on this one but it isn't a crazy argument.

[bhups]

We already pay for the public infrastructure through taxation. If the degree of taxation isn't suitable given the degree of use, there could be a corporate tax rate (I wouldn't support that, but it isn't unheard of).

This does not, however, give the government a blank check on an individual or a business's rights. We don't barter our rights for public benefits - we pay for them through taxation.

[brandonmenc]

Are you a driver paying, for example, the gas tax? Then you are already funding that infrastructure.

[ska]

If only it were that simple. Are you aware of anywhere where usage taxes cover all of the infrastructure?