Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WalterSear 3457 days ago
There's a lot of people on here discussing the stress of a new child.

I don't think they are differentiating between stress, that this study discusses, from lack of sleep, which also affects memory.

2 comments

I find getting too little sleep very stressful. I'm required to keep doing the same things, but less able to handle those demands. When I don't get enough sleep, I've got worse health, constant headaches, and neck aches. It's its own stressor, as well as having separate negative effects.
Yes, but that's a specific physical stressor, resulting in mental stress. It's not what is being examined in the article and modeled in the experiment.
That doesn't change the fact that lack of sleep is a stressor. I was replying to your statement:

> "I don't think they are differentiating between stress, that this study discusses, from lack of sleep, which also affects memory."

In practice the two will be impossible to tease apart at any rate. Stress and lack of sleep make a feedback loop. The more you feel like you're drowning, the harder it gets to find sleep. Adding nighttime feedings just throws gas on the fire.
From a fine grained point of view, yes, stress causes sleep problems.

However, stress is a result of, and not the cause of the sleep deprivation that comes with nursing and changing a child throughout the night.