Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jcadam 3465 days ago
I had to disable touch ID on my iPhone out of frustration. It works for me maybe 1 out of 10 times no matter which finger I try to use (my wife has no problem with hers).

But I've always had trouble with fingerprint readers. At the DMV, govt ID card office (back when I was in the Army), etc. "Place your finger on the scanner. Nope, try again.. press harder. No, harder."

I have no idea what's wrong with my fingers :|

4 comments

Certain professions have a big problem with fingerprints.

Most notable: brick masons. The fingerprints are damaged and smoothed out over the years by acids in the cement and the roughness of the bricks.

Rock climbers too. Finger prints just get worn down.
Have you tried registering the same finger 5x?
I've heard that people with hyperhydrosis have a lot of trouble with biometrics devices as well as smart phones. If your skin is too moist it just kinda gums up the works.
I have a lot of problems with touch screens. Some screens refuse to register my touch, and other screens register my touch before I even make contact with the screen. If you turn on developer tools in android and look at the "touches", you can see them registering all over if I have my fingers a cm or so above the screen.

I have really moist skin, so I wouldn't be surprised if this was the issue. I had a fingerprint reader on my gen 1 Motorola Atrix and that worked just fine though. I think the company that built that authentication system was purchased by Apple and used in the iPhones. I wonder if his wife would have the same issues with his phone, it might be that his fingerprint scanner is less sensitive.

Makes sense, my biggest annoyance with the fingerprint reader is that it doesn't work reliably if your finger is at all wet (like while cooking).
Sounds like low ridges that mess with the scanners.
I have scarring across my fingerprints that changes fairly frequently (serious injuries when younger coupled with powerlifting regularly now, unnoticable but definitely not static) I am an edge case but surprisingly only had infrequent issues.

I don't use thumb scanners anymore though as inevitably my finger will change! It definitely isn't for everyone.