Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by phs 3473 days ago
I am struck by how little attention is paid to the voting system: is it first past the post? Single transferrable vote?

The voting system determines the class of proposals that can be decided without voters needing to model each other's behavior to get what they want. Voters are forced to choose between what they want and what they think they can get; "I prefer candidate/policy A, but I think B is OK and stronger; I definitely don't want C. So I guess I'm voting B."

FPTP is only good for deciding boolean proposals. For selecting from a larger set of alternatives, STV allows voters to be more fearless ("First pick is A, second is B"), and so more honest.

Block chain-style distributed verification is good, but that shouldn't be the killer feature of this app.