Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Auzy83 5895 days ago
Firstly, who are encoding.com? Unless I'm mistaken, only a small percentage of the market use their services.

The same editors in Techcrunch who believe that H.264 won because of the results from one web encoding company, probably also believe Apple dominate the market after walking into an Applecentre, and that Techcrunch dominates the news market.

This is perhaps the most deceptive article I have ever seen. I am so sick of Apple users standing up for Steve Jobs with clearly misleading evidence. Doing so may help keep their stocks afloat, but its terrible journalism. No, H.264 hasn't won, and cannot in fact win because standards keep changing.

Also, Apple certainly doesn't dominate the market! Their sales figures are absolutely dwarfed by the rest of the market and whilst the flash-disabled iPad/iphone may be selling well, their sales figures are insignificant compared to the number of flash-compatible internet devices out there (and with Android getting flash, this will likely hold true).

If anything, due to the way that Steve Job's is treating developers, it's possible people will see what jerk's Apple are, and return the trend to flash again.

Anyway, I think it's too early to say though. Sooner or later browsers will decide on a common format, and it's unlikely to be H.264 (because of the patents, and the fact even companies don't like paying licensing fees). Furthermore, just because Steve Job's says "all video formats have patents", people interpret it wrongly to mean Xiph will get sued. It could be possible that Steve Job's is just being an idiot too (Steve Job's also is happy to give off the impression that OSX cannot get viruses).

Thing's will change soon, but it is difficult to say which format will win still.

2 comments

I agree with the first two paragraphs, I think you went a little nuts after that though.
I'd agree.. But my point for Apple is valid. Most of the people saying H.264 has won are simply agreeing with Steves view

  and return the trend to flash again.
Flash is not a codec. Flash can be used to serve H.264