Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wheelerwj 3485 days ago
they ask some of the most ridiculous questions trying to trip you and make you say stuff you don't mean or isn't true.

Like, "do you know any foreigners?" turns into "why didn't you disclose that telationship, did they pay you money?"

No matter what you say it opens up a new line of questioning for the investigators. That's why lawyers tell you to never talk to them, not even to try and clear things up.

1 comments

It's also a very ambiguous question that's hard to answer properly without asking for far more detail.

For example - what do they mean by "know"? What you think it means can be very different from how the investigators interpret it. Do only close friends and associates count? How about that co-worker who sits three cubicles away from you, who you don't consider a friend but talk about football with a few times a week while waiting for the coffee machine? Or the barista at Starbucks who has seen you every morning for the past 3 years and 'knows' you well enough to ask how you family is doing?

And then - what do they consider a foreigner? Anyone who has born in a foreign country, even if they are a citizen? Or landed immigrants? Or only people who currently reside in foreign countries?

It would be easy for someone to believe they were honestly answering 'no' to the question without realizing their assumptions about what is being asked are incorrect.

I don't blame investigators for asking questions like this, but people should think very carefully about answering the questions without legal counsel. There's usually just too much ambiguity in most questions (even simple ones) to be able to comprehend all of the possible meanings and implications of every word. Relying on your ability to recall things on-the-spot while being questioned in a high-stress situation also seems like a bit of a lose-lose proposition.

i definitely blame investigators. ask what you want to know, otherwise be prepared for false positives.

the most concerning part is that they dont care about the false positives.