Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Alphasite_ 3482 days ago
How is cheating an a professional game ('esport') not equivalent to financial fraud when cheating in an other professional game (physical sport) is?
2 comments

The parent is saying that it is in professional games, but that that doesn't mean it requires legislation making cheating in all games explicitly illegal. Penalties in sports are commonly enforced primarily through the organisations running the sport, and only some offenses even involve actual law. If you cause someone financial harm, it's very likely already illegal.

Match-fixing in professional games is clearly fraud, that doesn't mean that letting your friend win because it is his birthday should be prosecutable.

I'd personally be okay with making cheating in multiplayer games illegal (it's purely antisocial behavior that causes real financial harm and has no legitimate reason to exist), but prosecuting people who write code is beyond the pale.
"Foul on the shot"

"Oh, that wasn't a foul"

"Yes it was"

"Are you going to make a federal case about this?"

"Yes. Yes I am."

Cheating in physical sport is not fraud unless done with the intent to fix an outcome. Similarly, cheating is not always necessary to fix an outcome, but the penalty is the same.