Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by EvanMiller 3490 days ago
Nice interactive examples but I'm afraid the basic setup here doesn't make sense to me. The "atom" is defined as the average encoding of inputs with the feature ("faces with a smile"), but I'd think the proper definition should subtract off inputs without the feature (i.e. "smile" = "faces with a smile" minus "faces without a smile"). The way it's defined you end up adding an extra "average face" along with the feature of interest, which is clearly seen in "The Geometry of Thought Vectors" example -- the non-smiling woman isn't so much forced to smile as to have her face merged with that of a generic smiling woman.