Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by banachtarski 3497 days ago
> The first is less likely to require debugging in the first place.

I'm all for functional languages but this scares me a bit. What do you do when you need to debug something and everything ends up being harder to debug but "less likely to need debugging." I've actually run into this situation a number of times and faced with a sea of linked compound expressions, debugging can be a daunting proposition.
2 comments
chc 3497 days ago
It's still a net win in my experience. The minor inconvenience of inserting a few temporary variables to hold intermediate values is much less than the burden of all the additional reading and debugging needed when you spell out every step for everything you want to do.

It's kind of strange to me. We generally acknowledge that not repeating yourself and dividing responsibilities sensibly leads to better code that has fewer bugs and is easier to reason about. And yet when we consider doing the same thing with iteration, we say, "Whoa, hang on. Why can't we just write out the whole thing every time instead of factoring the common bits into a function?"

link
iampherocity 3497 days ago
Comment out all but the first and output the result. If it's what you expected, uncomment next line and output the result. Is it what you expected. Repeat... Debugging is just a specialized form of troubleshooting so the same rules apply. Bring the system to a known good, and increase until you find where it breaks.
link
banachtarski 3497 days ago
You have a ton of these types of statements. Which one do you apply the treatment too? Your approach only allows doing this troubleshooting approach to a single place at a time easily.
link
marcosdumay 3497 days ago
How do you debug several places at the same time?

You have a ton of those statements, that's why you organize them in functions, and go debugging high level functions before you go into lower level ones, and then into atomic statements.

Anyway, you'll almost certainly want to do that in an repl. I don't know if swift supports one, if not that would be a real drawback.

link
iampherocity 3497 days ago
They do, it's really slick how well they have it integrated.
link