Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by airesQ 3498 days ago
I really don't see how that strategy would work with open source projects. Wouldn't most contributions for the "extend" phase be open source?

Once open source, it's much harder to extinguish.

4 comments

It would probably be some proprietary extensions in something like systemD. Increase the complexity to code about 10x to eliminate the small devs, etc. Nothing we haven't seen with the open doc standard, ActiveX, Java portability, etc.

You have to think more business like. Why extinguish Linux when every copy running somewhere can give you licencing income. Maybe they'll partner with redhat and provide them something that has to be paid. Unlimited possibilities really.

Open source means nothing and is same easy to extinguish, it's only more visible when someone is trying to. Microsoft, Google, Apple do open source work for publicity, if you as a single developer want a change in a projects, you submit PR... and wait weeks. First you need to write RFC, at some point RFC will be discussed behind closed doors by corporatisation members, you can have your vote in it on GitHub, but nothing else as we saw once already with MS. All you can do is fix documentation and tests for them, means they get free labour to improve their products, you can have an important repo forked on GitHub.
So have you ever contributed to OSS projects by these companies? I ask because what you've described is definitely not the case from what I can see.
Nope. In fact, that term is almost always applied to open technology. Right now Red Hat is doing it to Linux and Google is doing it to the Web. See the list of examples on the linked article for more.
Mostly just ignore the parent comment, some people are inherently compelled to link a twenty year old business strategy on EVERY Microsoft-related thread.
I can see you aren't reading the current changes in ms db licencing costs, not moving a finger about Kronos to favour directx and the likes. What do you think changed in ms after 20 years? Them providing a cute text editor for Linux and now they are the good guys?