Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by leshow 3503 days ago
No, those don't really appeal to me. I think Elm had a great middle ground for a while pre-0.16 with Signals. I'm just disappointed at what I see as a lack of positive change for the language. The more stuff that becomes compiler magic the worse the language is going to get IMO.
1 comments
Skinney 3503 days ago
> The more stuff that becomes compiler magic the worse the language is going to get IMO.

Not sure what you mean here. Elm 0.18 has less compiler magic, not more.

link
HappyAndHarmles 3503 days ago
One such magic is the "comparable" thing. See http://reasonablypolymorphic.com/blog/elm-is-wrong and https://github.com/elm-lang/elm-compiler/issues/774
link
Skinney 3502 days ago
Yes, but that's not new in 0.18
link
leshow 3501 days ago
Did you read my comment? I mentioned the removal of Signals and it's replacement with the 'magic' Html.app
link
Skinney 3500 days ago
Html.App used to be a namespace, I suspect you mean Program? In any case, how is that any more, or less, magic than Signals? Considering that the compiler has removed syntax in later versions, later versions of Elm has less magic than earlier versions.
link