Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fsiefken 3526 days ago
Hi greggman, not enough for what? Do you mean usability? gitlab, github and bitbucket provide a GUI to git-LFS. Or do you mean not enough documentation or a technical limitation like maximum file size or check-in/out speed or just bugs?
1 comments
to3m 3526 days ago
Needs file locking too. Looks like GitLab sort-of has you covered, though: https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/file_lock.html

On the other hand, it seems like it makes you wait until you're trying to do a git push before you find out somebody else has it locked already - which seems a bit cruel. The more traditional approach is for the file to be read-only in your working copy, and you use the version control client program to make it writeable (and it then performs the appropriate checks). So if you omit to consult the client program first, you'll get no further than your first attempt to save before you find out.

link
jobvandervoort 3526 days ago
You can see whether a file is locked in the UI, but we'd be happy to take any feedback on how to further improve this.
link
greggman 3526 days ago
You need to know it's locked when you open it. Which means you need plugins for popular software. Photoshop, Maya, Unity, 3DSMax, Blender, etc.

P4 has many of these integrations so that artist and other non-technical people will know the moment they open the file that if they want to edit it they need to check it out. Similarly they can choose to check in the changes directly from their asset editing app, not from some separate app. They also need an easy way to find out who has it checked out so they can go over to that person and ask when they'll be able to edit it or if the person forgot to check in their changes.

https://www.perforce.com/product/components/perforce-plugin-...

I've written some in the past as well (http://mayasvn.sourceforge.net/) that would not just check in a Maya file but also check in all the referenced files (otherwise an artist checks in the asset but there are lots of missing textures).

On a subnote: Asking the artist "check this in?" on each save is a bad UX. I tried that and the artists complained since they save all the time (in case their app crashes).

link