Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eivarv 3531 days ago
I get what you mean, but as far as I can see your first two paragraphs only amount to conjecture. I don't see how you can draw any conclusions about ADHD from that.

I do know of these cases, of course, but the field of mental illness is very much different today than what it was in the days of "Hyesteria" - both with regards to diagnostics, and to research. For instance, there are well known structural and functional abnormalities associated with certain mental illnesses - which would seem to imply that the current categorizations aren't completely off.

While you may be right in the technical sense that future research can make our current understanding obsolete, I don't think there's any doubt that some people suffer as a consequence of what is currently conceptualised as a behavioural disorder called ADHD.

1 comments

Saying future generations will see it differently does not deny that people are genuinely suffering currently. I have two special needs sons. Their issues have benefited tremendously from dietary changes, among other things.