[1812calif]

You are speaking of basically an IP-based version of the spamhaus blacklist. For general http or TCP protocol.

I, for one, would be fine with a general internet citizen losing access if they have a compromised device. I suspect this is how we will go -- your home security cam was used in an attack, now every single website you visit for XXXXXXXX days gives you a CAPTCHA.

I maintain the crucial element is informing people why they have that hassle. Add extra friction, but not inhibit what they can do, because they are unable and unwilling to secure their devices.

Yes, this affects the internet-uneducated disproportionately. Yes, I think it is the responsibility of anyone with a broadband connection to understand the responsibilities that come with it.

No, I do not expect grandma to learn this. I expect her to deal with a crippled internet because they are not able to fix their pollution.