Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by flukus 3535 days ago
I will, they've been clear about it being a work in progress.

There are a lot of other people saying how amazing it is though, when functionality wise it's only just coming up to par with cygwin.

Edit - functionality wise as a usable bash shell, it's an acceptable linux virtual machine already.
2 comments
cheiVia0 3535 days ago
It is not a virtual machine and doesn't involve Linux in any way. It is an implementation of the Linux syscalls for the Windows kernel.
link
flukus 3535 days ago
Why does this trigger so many people?
link
cheiVia0 3535 days ago
https://www.xkcd.com/386/
link
TazeTSchnitzel 3535 days ago
Why is “trigger” used jokingly now? Unless you think the people responding have PTSD or a similar condition.
link
flukus 3534 days ago
Because self diagnosed PTSD sufferers on Tumblr made a mockery of it.

The word has uses outside of the PTSD context though, like gun or database triggers.

link
TazeTSchnitzel 3534 days ago
> Because self diagnosed PTSD sufferers on Tumblr made a mockery of it.

Why would them being self-diagnosed matter? Why would you react to it having been “made a mockery of” by reinforcing this supposed mockery? It only makes it worse for people who have to deal with it.

link
flukus 3534 days ago
> Why would them being self-diagnosed matter?

Because the self diagnosis is largely made up by people who don't understand what PTSD even is. It's like someone declaring they have cancer without going to a doctor.

> Why would you react to it having been “made a mockery of” by reinforcing this supposed mockery?

Because it's become part of the lexicon now. I don't think there's any going back. My usage was the "new" usage, no relation to PTSD was intended.

link
tracker1 3535 days ago
I have to agree... I'm still using the bash that comes with git for windows. It actually works (mostly) as one would expect it to work.

Also, not being able to edit the WSL filesystem from inside a windows editor is a huge loss in terms of usage. It's worse than using Samba/CIFS to share a directory and edit across to a full VM. I happen to like my gui editor, but prefer to run in Linux.

link
WorldMaker 3534 days ago
If you had to you can touch things in the WSL VolFS by browsing the appropriate %AppData% subfolder. I'm presuming Microsoft isn't encouraging that right now with this Interop tooling for several reasons.

At a guess one of them might be that apparently the Unix things like permissions and Unix-style metadata are stored in NTFS alternate streams (~"resource forks") that they may be worried some Windows programs might not handle quite right (ie, accidentally mangle/remove/destroy).

link
tracker1 3534 days ago
It actually doesn't work right, and MS just closed the issue. I'd be fine with cifs automounts in the linux subsystem for windows file directories... I mean it may take a little work, but in the end, I want to edit files with a windows gui editor, and run them via the LSW applications. Until I can do that, it's an also ran on the desktop... and until it can be used for docker with linux containers on the server, it doesn't do much use there either.
link
WorldMaker 3534 days ago
Why can't you keep the shared files that you want to GUI edit somewhere under /mnt/?/* in a normal NTFS folder? That works fine already today.

I'm using Bash on Ubuntu on Windows for Jekyll (because installing and keeping up to date Ruby on Windows is a terrible experience and this is a much nicer alternative). My files are in D:\Repos\..., I'll have VSCode open and Jekyll running in Bash in the equivalent /mnt/d/Repos/...

link