Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zaroth 3539 days ago
It looks really pretty. But, am I right in saying that this all works by sending all your critical business data to Microsoft servers to run the analysis and generate the reports? Businesses actually do this?

Why would you send data offsite to generate pretty graphs of it? Is this really not available as a self-hosted service?

2 comments

Microsoft is cloud-first in development now.

There is a Power BI Desktop program that is 100% free as in beer available, which runs a private instance of an in-memory columnstore OLAP engine, Power Pivot (same internals as SSAS). It also includes the reporting layer and Power Query, a lightweight ETL tool.

There is an on-prem version of Power BI that the team has committed to including as a feature of SSRS in SQL Server 2016, but the timeline is still fuzzy.

The point of the Power BI hosted portal is not the pretty visuals, but a low-maintenance collaboration portal that includes natural language Q&A on your data, automatic analysis to identify trends in the data, and tight integration with Office 365.

If you want to go on-prem, there is a third party named Pyramid Analytics which offers a solution that allows Power BI hosting.

Power BI is actually a continuation of a number of products. If you want a somewhat equivalent experience on-prem, you can use Power Pivot in Excel (2010+), with Power View on SharePoint (SSRS 2012+, SharePoint 2010+), which gives you an older Silverlight-based report engine that has similar capabilities.

The real useful piece, though is the semantic layer in Power Pivot, which is identical to SSAS. The power in any BI tool is not the reporting layer (though Power View is a pretty good one for the use cases it targets), but in the power and expressivity of the data model. This is an area where Microsoft shines.

I could go on for hours about this - I work in technical presales (and do at least 50% time in a technical delivery role) for an analytics consulting firm that is a Microsoft partner.

Of course they have on-prem versions. A lot of people are content with using cloud services though, so on-prem solutions cost a pretty penny.
See my sibling. There is no Microsoft offering for on-prem Power BI. You can get close to it with sibling products on SharePoint.

There is a third party offering an on-prem solution.

There's Pyramid Analytics which is officially endorsed by Microsoft as "Power Bi onprem" and present on the Power BI's homepage.
Pyramid is the third party I mentioned in my post. It is not a Microsoft product, as I mentioned in my post.

Pyramid offers .pbix file hosting and web rendering. It does not offer the Power BI portal that is a cloud offering from Microsoft. There is a big difference between these things.