Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by _swa8 3535 days ago
It still seems to be OK to bring Note 7s on airplanes. Not bottles of water, though, that's too dangerous.
5 comments

I see the point you're trying to make; the authorities apparently accept a risk in terms of expensive equipment produced by corporations with strong lobbying funds, but decline that risk in terms of bottled liquids.

One fact that is overlooked is that there is actually a limit on the lithium-equivalent permitted per passenger just like there is a liquid-volume limit.

Last time I checked, the total maximum carry-on lithium-equivalent was 25 grammes which was about four smartphone batteries or two-dozen AA cells. Now as to whether that's an acceptable risk is for someone else more knowlegeable to evaluate.

Not sure if you've been in an airport, but you can buy a bottle of water and bring it on an airplane.
Yeah, and it costs 10x as much as in a regular super market, despite being the same water.

I really, really dislike flying. Not because of the flying itself, but because of being treated like a potential terrorist all the time.

So carry an empty bottle/tumbler/thermos and fill it up at the water fountain?
You're not allowed to do so, at least when I tried taking an empty bottle it was confiscated (Munich Airport, EDDM).
Strange, I've been traveling with a 500cc refillable water bottle forever, never had any trouble (Germany, Netherlands, East Asia). Maybe it helps that my bottle is designed to be refilled, and not just an empty bottle from the supermarket.
That's definitely not true for any airports in the US. Finally a category where US airport security is more sane.
Commonly there is no water fountain.
I've seen a lot of airports (recently PDX and O'Hare) that have water bottle filler up dispensers past security.
There is always a bathroom.
Yes ... but sometimes only hot water is available, and at all times the quality of water not marked 'drinking water' could in principle be suspect (it might come via a tank somewhere — this is certainly common in old UK domestic plumbing — and the tank might have dead rat in it, etc.).
The problem is that with a water bottle, you can immediately see it's some kind of liquid on the x-ray and disallow it during inspection, whereas the Note 7 isn't immediately apparent when inspected from afar. While I don't agree with the liquid ban, it's much easier to ban a liquid than it is to ban a specific model of a phone.
If the radio is on you can watch for the MAC address.
Yes I'd love for the TSA to invest in MAC address scanning devices..
Last time I was on an airplane the crew disallowed all Note 7s being turned on or being charged. I'm not sure if it was seriously enforced, but it was announced.
You can bring bottles of water onto airplanes...
Only if you buy is after security. Maybe we're gonna have to buy phones now too :)
You can bring it on the Ola E if you bought it in the airport. So you can't take a bottle of water through security check, but you can take a note 7.