Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 1474295912 3546 days ago
> The tone also angered me

I Read the article and I understand that it's flawed in some parts. However, that's exactly how the non-western major world civilisations are called. Barbarians, mysticals and unscientific etc are the words used to describe them. I would urge you to look past the eurocenticism as I did and you'll discover that there's truth in the facts.

If we leave out the mislabeling of images, the fact remains that the eastern world was in fact more connected, advanced and globalised compared to Rome.
3 comments
YeGoblynQueenne 3546 days ago
>> However, that's exactly how the non-western major world civilisations are called. Barbarians, mysticals and unscientific etc are the words used to describe them.

"Barbarian" though is a Greek word, used by Greeks to describe anyone speaking a language that wasn't the Greek language. I'm guessing the article either ignores this or uses "barbarian" as a translation of a similar term used in the Far Eastern world, and which I don't know. I'm pretty sure there must have been one.

link
digi_owl 3546 days ago
May have been the origin of the term, but these days it is basically "any culture that have practices and norm we do not understand and deem inferior to our own".
link
Veen 3546 days ago
> we do not understand and deem inferior to our own

Of course, those two things don't have to go together. It's perfectly reasonable to understand something and deem it inferior. And deeming it inferior isn't necessarily an indication that something isn't understood.

link
jbmorgado 3546 days ago
No they are not, that's just a lie. The school in Europe doesn't talk that much about the East compared to the West is true (and it makes perfect sense), but it holds many parts of the East to high regard and clearly points their cultural advancement in many areas.

The "Barbarians" we learn in school are exactly from Europe, not from Asia and the term is directed towards the German tribes and the Nordic ones.

link
jomamaxx 3546 days ago
"that's exactly how the non-western major world civilisations are called. "

Everyone called everyone else 'Barbarian' - that does not mean they were.

The Germanic tribes at the time were objectively, probably 'Barbarians' ... that's roughly objective.

But not the rest.

Medium is a 'cultural marxism' type website, they are 'non self aware social prog' type people there.

Some good stuff that goes of the hinges sometime.

link