Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ajg1977 5909 days ago
Actually it sounds more like they have completely changed their business plan.

Before: Provide communities and companies the software and hosting that enabled the creation of high-quality Q&A sites.

Now: Create a carefully cultivated garden of user-maintained Q&A sites with active communities and minimal overlap.

And that's fine of course, but it seems a little odd to judge the former was failing (after what, six months?) by using the goals of the second as a criteria for success.
1 comments
xelipe 5909 days ago
Their new business model is more complicated than their previous business model. The five steps to citizenship seems like a weird concept. People that want to host a Q&A site like these don't want to be told they aren't good enough to have a top-level domain. Imagine wanting a blog and WordPress or Tumblr thought you undeserving of a top-level domain. Stack Exchange 2.0 has more steps to have a top-level domain site than the Chinese government has for it's citizens to acquire a domain. I'm sure there is a good Rails/PHP Q&A clone webapp.
link
thenbrent 5909 days ago
Hear hear.

A Q&A site is not a piece of legistlation; it's an entreneurial endeavour.

It's best to leave entrepreneurs to be free to create, experiment and adapt.

Stackexhange will miss out on some great sites by rejecting them before they even get a start. The best sites will be those where the founder/s constantly adapt the site to demands of the community, not those who have the best idea upfront.

But as you say, that's where the OSS optios come in. :)

link
Tawheed 5909 days ago
Sounds like a design by committee
link
robryan 5909 days ago
Well it's not really like anyone will be running these sites independent of Joel, Jeff and co. So really this is just a mostly automated method of spinning off the software and getting a vibrant community at launch like SO had rather than stabbing in the dark at what people actually want.
link
tcdent 5909 days ago
Imagine wanting a blog and WordPress or Tumblr thought you undeserving of a top-level domain.

And just look at how many crap blogs are on each of those platforms. Their goal is to curate quality content and the free-reign model has already proven itself to be incapable of it.

link