Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by colechristensen 3560 days ago
>My personal opinion is that we should absolutely say no

We don't disagree that there's a problem: medically fighting to the last breath should be replaced by gracefully accepting the end at the appropriate time (for both cost reasons and for the quality of life at the end for the patient, etc.)

We do disagree on how. If you want to make progress on that front we should have education and cultural growth around accepting death and doing what's best at the end for doctors, patients, and families. We shouldn't have a bureaucrat forcing the decision on anyone.

---

>This current issue with epipen is a simple issue of rent seeking

It's not an issue of rent seeking specifically, but abusing government granted monopolies (patent protection, trademark protection, forcing schools to buy, etc)

> Are you suggesting we spend more than we can get away with hoping the slimeball companies will reinvest their profits into R&D?

No, the high cost of R&D and slimeball behavior are often intermixed, but separate issues. I'm suggesting that a whole lot of the money for expensive drugs is actually going towards R&D. Lots of foreign countries are getting steep discounts and not paying equal shares because the drug companies are taking the path of least resistance. They can get funded in America more easily so they don't fight as much in places that are more difficult to win.

America couldn't magically get the foreign prices because the R&D money wouldn't appear from anywhere else. America's prices go down but the rest of the world's prices go up to meet in the middle ... or a lot less drug research happens (or a bit of both)

There are lots of things happening, and a lot of the problems are due to lacking regulation. What can get patented and for how long is wrong; more research should be publicly funded with stipulations that the results are free to society; drug approval mechanisms need to be more efficient; some barriers between national drug markets need to be broken down (you should be able to sell across borders between economically equal nations)

There are a lot of things which could lead to a healthier medical environment which aren't being done. We've got some small reforms out of the way, but there are still huge inefficiencies.