Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by adimitrov 3559 days ago
That's the big problem with TTIP: those who negotiated it (on the EU side at least) weren't elected representatives. In fact, elected representatives only very recently received very limited access to the negotiation documents themselves. In Germany, access was granted to members of parliament only January this year. Even so, they weren't even allowed to carry electronic devices or pen-and-paper notebooks.

This is why TTIP, no matter the content, is undemocratic. As is CETA.

2 comments

Elected representatives could not negotiate the deal themselves because it is way too technical. So the actual negotiators were given a mandate by the elected representatives. Elected representatives then get to decide whether they will vote for the deal. TTIP is dead because it's become clear the deal will not get approval from all representatives, in part because of public disapproval. In conclusion, TTIP _is_ democratic.
If the deal is too technical to negotiate how can the elected representative possibly decide if they should vote for it as they by definition can't understand it?
> Elected representatives could not negotiate the deal themselves because it is way too technical.

It really isn't ...

Could you elaborate?
Fair point, but then surely it is the EU that is undemocratic rather than TTIP.