Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by otterley 3554 days ago
Personally, I would have preferred you waited until you could release all the documents at once. I admit I was interested, but I've seen too many people and organizations start a conversation but never finish it or show the goods. It's misleading and unfair to dangle a solution when all you really have is a problem.

Take, for example, this post from CoreOS back in March 2016 that suggested that they might know a way to improve systemd-journald performance: https://coreos.com/blog/eliminating-journald-delays-part-1.h...

It smelled suspicious, but its release generated a bunch of noise on HN anyway. And they never followed up with subsequent parts, which suggests to me that they never found a solution in the first place.

I'm not suggesting that GitHub is blowing smoke -- if you truly have a solution, that's great! But there's no harm in gathering documentation and source code and cleaning it up and waiting until it's good and ready to go. Otherwise, I frankly mistrust the motives and abilities of those involved. Call me cynical if you must.

To paraphrase from another industry, "sell no wine before its time." There's a lot of wisdom there that is equally applicable to products in our industry too.

1 comments

As if by magic, part 2 has just appeared. (-: See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12603322 .