Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gohrt 3562 days ago
> Thus, there are fantastic lawyers working at Sierra Club or NRDC, but they're not going to have the same record of wins as similarly-good lawyers at a big New York firm.

Not a problem for the analysis of law firms. Sierra Club is a less effective law firm than the big New York firm.

1 comments

> Not a problem for the analysis of law firms. Sierra Club is a less effective law firm than the big New York firm.

Why is this not a problem? The parent comment was saying that the Sierra Club takes harder cases and is often the plaintiff, not the defendant, so they may be more effective as a law firm but have worse numbers because the win/loss numbers don't mean the same things in different contexts.

It's also worth nothing that the Sierra Club isn't a law firm at all. It's an environmental organization that, among many other things, sometimes uses the legal system to advance its goals.