Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Artoemius 3574 days ago
Not seriously. But I wouldn't seriously argue that it is always rational to follow the law, either. Sometimes you really need the money.
1 comments

Actually, not if you're a government. The last time they didn't follow the letter of the law, we started torturing people again because we were really hungry.

Most of our laws that exist at extremes (no torture, Geneva Convention) exist as a reaction against what did happen the last time a stressful situation was lawless, and a rational check against the next time stress brings up a possible irrational reaction.

Stealing food should always be a crime - it let's us then consider the circumstances surrounding the action, and forgive the crime. (This is the basic argument against mandatory sentencing. It removes empathy, which makes us less than human.)