Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nordify 3583 days ago
No, but everything that's not transit is a fixed cost and thus as long as the internal network is properly designed and implemented, only transit costs matter. The rest (i.e. the fixed costs) will be covered by the monthly subscription fee.
2 comments
mseebach 3583 days ago
It is very expensive fixed cost that the customers need to pay the amortisation of. Also, it's only fixed as long as it's never maintained or until it needs to be upgraded. You're not going to be satisfied with 25mbit a few years from now.
link
nordify 3583 days ago
Maintenance is a percentage of the fixed costs. Upgrades replace old equipment as they have been paid off and decommissioned, so just another fixed cost that replaces the old fixed cost.

So fixed costs all around.

link
mseebach 3583 days ago
That certainly depends. But just because a cost is fixed doesn't mean it's free or low.
link
nordify 3583 days ago
I made no promises of either free or low.
link
mseebach 3583 days ago
That was literally the premise of the thread. So your entire errand was pointing out the blatantly obviously fact that fixed costs are fixed?
link
nordify 3583 days ago
> That was literally the premise of the thread.

No it wasn't. The thread starter discussed how broadband connections should be marketed, and the suggestion was to use guaranteed bandwidth as a measure.

This then digressed into the cost of bandwidth, where one poster took it totally off the rails by assuming transit costs $25 per Mbps, when the true cost is two decades lower.

The fixed cost of providing guaranteed bandwidth in the last mile pales compared to costs like $25 per Mbps, which was my point. The last mile is a fixed cost and even high amounts of guaranteed bandwidth in the last mile are fixed costs which are easily covered by the monthly subscription fee.

That does not mean that the fixed costs are free or low by absolute dollar terms.

So there.

link
rhino369 3583 days ago
It would take a massive upgrade to most ISP internal networks to allow each home to use 25 mbit at the same time. There are bottlenecks that would have to replaced.
link
nordify 3583 days ago
True, but it would still be a fixed cost to upgrade.
link