Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JshWright 3590 days ago
I don't understand why a prepackaged vial/syringe kit isn't readily available for epinephrine. It works just fine for glucagon...

http://www.childrenwithdiabetes.com/d_0n_022.htm

We're literally talking about $1 worth of epinephrine, a $0.50 syringe, and a couple cents worth of injection molded plastic case...

1 comments

Probably because that is not what matters. With the epipen, I can just jam it into my daughters thigh, straight through thick winter clothing and all. I don't need to ensure she gets the dosage right, nor that the syringe doesn't break.
My point is that with a very slight increase in the complexity of the process, you could have a _dramatic_ reduction in cost.

New York State is actually in the process of transitioning EMTs from EpiPens to vial/syringe kits.

EMTs are not the target customer of epipens. They work with life-threatening situations day after day. To a kindergarten teacher, if a child if having an anaphylactic chock, this is very far from a "very slight increase in complexity".

Just to ground the situation, the kindergarten teachers at my daughters place are already freaked out from the thought of having to administer an epipen. I can't even start to imagine how they would handle a syringe and a bottle.

There are thousands of people out there who carry IM Glucagon kits, an similarly time sensitive medication, intended to be administered by untrained bystanders. If it works for Glucagon, I see no reason it can't work for Epinephrine. In reality, there's no need for a vial, the syringe can be prefilled with the correct dose.