Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jkubicek 3591 days ago
If we took a fleet of tug-boats and towed this ice to the Middle East, I wonder how long the fresh water would last?
6 comments

An interesting theoretical thought exercise.

The money and fuel bill for tugboats sufficient to move that would probably be better spent on massive fields of photovoltaics and electricity-intensive seawater desalination equipment...

What if this frozen ice contains disease vectors still dormant and if we don't have immunity to them they might wipe out all life on earth.
What about nuclear powered boats? Russia has a fleet of nuclear powered ice breakers.
6000 square kilometers of ice.
Take smaller chunks of it.
How small to become profitable? You'll see, this ends in a no win situation fast. Sadly enough.
Build giant sails!
Or -- while we're thinking geoengineering -- could we limit how much ice breaks off by deliberately making a cut (or a series of breaks in the ice) from the current end of the crack straight out to sea?
If that would work, then there wouldn't be a crack there in the first place.
Why?
Because the crack isn't the fundamental problem. The problem is that the ice sheet is too small to resist temperature changes. Purposefully making the ice sheet smaller yet only exacerbates the problem.

The only reason anyone cares that there is a crack is because it implies that the ice is shrinking.

Why does a bigger span of ice make it more resistant to temperature changes?
Lower surface area and higher albedo.
"If we took a fleet of tug-boats and towed this ice to the Middle East,"

Not easy. This was a problem my high school math tutor, a glaciologist [0],[1] discussed with me one evening doing some applied math.

From memory, using a tug to pull an iceberg from Antartica to the Australian mainland would be difficult because of the forces involved. As the tug would try to pull the iceberg, the iceberg itself is acted on by other forces (gravity, currents). The tug pulling the iceberg, connected by a cable would be acted on by the forces applied by the iceberg resulting in the berg and tug rotating in circles around each other. [2] Adding another tug has similar problems.

The idea isn't stupid, it's just the physics get in the way of achieving a result.

[0] 1970 - 2003 http://www.antarctica.gov.au/news/2003/antarctic-ice-man-and...

[1] 2003 - 2016 https://rmdb.research.utas.edu.au/public/rmdb/q/indiv_detail...

[2] If memory serves me, Jo used 'moments of inertia' to describe this problem ~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_moments_of_inertia

There are not enough boats in the world to move this object. It's gonna go where it wants.
Can someone say "trading spaces" qoute