Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Houshalter 3595 days ago
Here's something I've been thinking about recently. Why can't we replace public transit with automatically routed busses? You could order a bus like you would an Uber, and the bus would automatically come up with the most efficient route to meet everyone's demand.

Then tax cars on the road to reduce congestion as the busses use the road more efficiently.

2 comments

The first part doesn't work so well without the second part (buses are terrible on congested roads) and the second part is unlikely to work well without the first (who'd accept that tax?).

Really, you'd need to do these both at once and getting support for such a thing would be extraordinarily difficult without it being proven first.

Also, I doubt it could work as well or better than trams/streetcars in dense areas. I mean the model used by trams/light rail in European cities (the one that comes to my mind is Zurich) rather than that used by Muni. In Zurich there's a stop every 2-3 blocks and it'll usually have a tram coming within a few minutes. I've seen cities were a wait longer than 3 minutes during the day is rare.

A bus like you describe would certainly be more convenient (it can turn and go down streets without rails, as well as come to pick me up) but I'm not sure it would be better overall (the pickup costs time that's lost by the current passengers of the bus for example).

What's the difference between a tram and a bus? Rails? Dedicated stops? Having to share the route with other vehicles?

Well we could solve the second two problems, and not needing rails seems like an advantage.

That sounds like UberPool. I'd be interested to see whether larger, less nimble vehicles would make it better or worse. It doesn't seem obvious either way.