[a4agarwal]

You're kidding, right? iPhotos email button for photos is exactly my point. There should be intelligent communication and data sharing between apps, not at the Finder level.

in iPhoto, there's a preference to set which email client it sends to

[Tichy]

What if I want to do something else with my photo, that iPhoto doesn't yet have a button for? How does a universal interface look like, that allows arbitrary other apps to get photos from iPhoto?

Intents on Android do something like that, but I am not sure how much they live up to their potential yet.

I am new to iPhoto and don't know about the config. I saw other people having problems with emailing photos from iPhoto, too.

Not everything Apple does or want is automatically the best way of doing things. This model they push works best if all applications are from the same vendor. Guess who has a vested interest in pushing that model?

Will all apps have the same kind of config? Or will I have to learn each new app, to make it work with another app? If I don't want to listen to my MP3s in iTunes, what do i do? Suppose I can send photos from iPhoto to Photoshop (or should I request them from within Photoshop, or should it work both ways?). Can I send them to The Gimp, too? If the Gimp adds a "request from iPhoto" button, will it add a "request from <Flickr|someOtherPhotoApp>" button, too? Will Photoshop?

Because the file system is pretty simple and universal. It's true that a lot of people have some trouble with it, but there might be trouble with the alternatives, too.

I think something like desktop search has maybe a better chance than the shiny GUIs.

[GHFigs]

What if I want to do something else with my photo, that iPhoto doesn't yet have a button for? How does a universal interface look like, that allows arbitrary other apps to get photos from iPhoto?

The email export function is implemented with AppleScript. To add support for Thunderbird (for example) just means writing a similar script for it. Indeed, it appears that someone has already done so: http://softpixel.com/~cwright/programming/iPhoto/

Note that this is a minor hack, to get the button within iPhoto to support Thunderbird. It isn't necessary to get the same function as a regular Scripts menu item. Such scripts can be written in AppleScript, Ruby[1], Python, and Objective-C.

This is not really a solution to the more general problem being discussed, but I thought it worth mentioning.

[1]: http://developer.apple.com/mac/library/documentation/cocoa/C...

[a4agarwal]

"How does a universal interface look like, that allows arbitrary other apps to get photos from iPhoto"

Apple has an iLife media browser. It lets any application access any of the media on your system, including photos and music.