Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by forkqueue 5921 days ago
Yup, DTrace and ZFS are pretty much the only things Solaris brings to the table above what Linux offers.

Interestingly I've never come across any pure Solaris shops that run ZFS, I suppose because if you're conservative enough only to use Solaris, you're too conservative to trust ZFS.
3 comments
buster 5921 days ago
Zones too. I think they offer more then what the usual jail does. Never really used both of them, but.. yeah, zones sound nice, too :)

Also, solaris is probably the most stable OS i've ever worked with.

link
forkqueue 5921 days ago
Solaris zones are awful, and a good example of where Linux is far superior to Solaris. The creators of Zones seemed to have user-mode-Linux as their model, and it shares most of the annoyances of that too. It's not virtualization, and it's not a jail - it's a middle ground which is good for neither.

Agree with you to some extent on stability - I've seen Solaris boxes with a load of 300+ still up and running although unusably slow, where Linux would almost certainly have died from resource starvation. In general use, both Linux and Solaris are pretty damn reliable though.

link
buster 5920 days ago
Whats so bad about zones? It's clear that they are no virtualization. As you said it's a middleground, more capable as jails but not virtual, which is fine if you don't need it?
link
thibaut_barrere 5921 days ago
I'd add SMF (unless you know about something similar that's built-in into Linux ?).
link
koenigdavidmj 5920 days ago
What does that get me over Upstart or the other event-driven init systems?

(This is a question of genuine curiosity. SMF has led to many headaches when I've had to deal with it, simply because it didn't seem to comply with normal conventions like returning nonzero for failure or actually printing what goes wrong to the console.)

EDIT: add trailing parenthesis.

link
nailer 5920 days ago
XML based config files!

Just kidding.

link
alnayyir 5921 days ago
DTrace and ZFS are both available on FreeBSD.

Call me a BSD bigot (even though I use Linux/OS X at work) but I really fail to see any rational reason to use Solaris at this point.

We have a Solaris database + filestore at work, mostly for Z-raid, but now that FreeBSD has ZFS, when it gets EOL'd (with a vicious grin on my face) it's going to be a BSD box that replaces it.

link