Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Shivetya 3600 days ago
well their means to score countries is contrived enough to be "we knew the results before we knew the facts". As in any strong economy is bad
1 comments

More like a strong economy == lots of energy use, and lots of energy use == lots of pollution, because the world uses lots of dirty energy.

The fact that one can guess some results ahead of time doesn't cast doubt on the results, any more than, after coughing blood and 40 years of smoking, a positive cancer diagnosis is suspect.

I rate this rhetorical tactic a 3: poor composition, not enough work either developing the implication of skullduggery or making it more subtle, missed opportunities for additional attacks on reporters' credibility.