Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by berberous 3613 days ago
PiP looks great. There's nothing stopping you from opening two browser windows side by side, but that's a huge pain. I don't want all the various other parts of the webpage showing, or to have to resize the window manually to just show the video. I just want to pop-out the video only. I love the feature on my iPad. I think when you try it, you may grow to appreciate it.
2 comments

> PiP looks great.

For me at least, there is no way to look at that screenshot of a space-wasting yet partially occluded fullscreen app with an awkwardly-placed naked video component on top of it and say it "looks great".

> windows side by side, but that's a huge pain

Window positioning on OS X is a huge pain because literally no work has been done on this by Apple for many years now. Other OSes all have window snapping and other conveniences, but on OS X I need 3rd-party software for that. What's more is that PiP is a barely adequate specialized component from iOS. The more generalized desktop element would instead have allowed to "PiP" any window content I choose by essentially being an always-on-top decorator-less partial window. But the way they are presenting it is not going to be empowering for desktop users in any way. It's a thoughtlessly ported component from the more unpleasant corners of the Youtube iOS app.

There is window snapping in macOS, websearch for Sierra window snapping.
Very similiar feature in Opera desktop since 4 month now [1]. It works pretty good on Windows, Mac and Linux.

[1] http://www.opera.com/blogs/desktop/2016/04/opera-beta-update...