Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zer0gravity 3614 days ago
When engineers start acting like religious people it's time to run...
2 comments

Please replace the term "religious people" with "people of color" and understand the harm you are doing in your discourse. It is blatant prejudice.
What I'm suggesting is that in engineering is better to test truths by applying logic and not just take them for granted by faith.

Please don't generalize my words and don't use them to activate your own prejudice..

> your own prejudice..

Which is?

By the way, I agree completely with the wording "not just take them for granted by faith." It is much more precise and to the point.

> > your own prejudice..

> Which is?

A desire to feel offended and outraged?

Weak tea, my friend. Even if it were true... that's not a prejudice. Please try again. I'm patient.
I think the correct term to use in this case, is "When engineers start acting religiously..."

As a person doesn't need a religion, to act religious; I can be religious about canned goods or martial arts, or perhaps, engineering.

I do agree that using the term "religious people", while the meaning is understood, makes a generalised assumption about a larger group of people who do not all adhere to the imagined stereotype, and it casts them in a negative light.

I suppose that the point you're making is that zer0gravity used the term "religious people", and that seems to be acceptable to most people, few object to it; whereas "people of color" or any other term that is deemed unacceptable to make that kind of negative assumption about, would not be okay. And that's a rather big double-standard.

Regardless though, the meaning that zer0gravity was trying to convey, was clear and understood. I think taking up offence at zer0gravity's comment and use of the term "religious people" just detracts from the topic being discussed; and I highly doubt any ground will be crossed on the point you're trying to make; at least on this page and topic.

True, though this story sounded more like one engineer convinced of his godhood and a bunch of clueless managers who ensure that the only way you can keep your job is to believe in the greatness of the solution and its author...