[raverbashing]

> or they have taken our community-created page with all 5-star reviews completely off the site

Is this page inside Yelp? You have two business pages on Yelp?

What I could suggest is that you get (old) Yelp users to put (legitimate - not exaggerated) comments on your page.

And of course, you can make a video lambasting them on YT as well.

[svskeptic]

There is only one page. The community-created one. As a business, we never created one.

If you google "yelp $business", you can find this page today. If you go to yelp.com and search for "$business", it used to be there. But, in the last week, it was taken off the search results and now a competitor is shown as a search result instead.

Going back to the users is not feasible for us, because we don't know who they are! They are some of our customers who felt the service was great enough to leave glowing reviews. We didn't solicit it.

What actions to take is an interesting discussion for us. Ethics aside, we just might cave and pay the Yelp mafia tax, as a cost of doing business. Which is what they want. And we want to get on with our business.

Edit: $business = 'Real Business Name';

[raverbashing]

When you mean google "yelp $business" is $business like "chinese restaurante" or the actual name?

All pages are "community created", you can try to recreate the page if your page is gone, you go to "Write a review", search for it and then "Add a Business"

Of course you might pay, or take them to court as well