Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by aresant 3611 days ago
This article makes it sound like Google frittered away $1b on the "X" lab last quarter.

X lab includes self driving car, Goog Glass, Project Tango (editorializing here but Tango is badass!), more crazier bets (1)

Ok, some crazy stuff there - pretty pretty risky.

Wow $1b last quarter for that stuff.

Geez corporate responsibility grumble grumble, stupid silicon valley assholes snark snark.

But wait, spend 30 seconds doing research and in reality the $859m headline is actually referring to Alphabet's line item "Other Bets"

"Other Bets" includes Nest, Google Fiber, Google Ventures, and Verily among others(2)

Nest = iot + Tony Fadell (pre fallout) looked like a damn good way to beat Apple to a new important consumer market. Still holding out hope.

Google Fiber = fast speed is fundamental to Google's biz, heck they could probably look at this as CapEx. Please come to my 'hood!

Google Ventures = bought $258m of Uber stock @ $3.6b valuation. What's that a 20x so far? Pays for entire fund's lifetime by several multiples? Lots of other follow-rounds that make sense (3)

Verily = profitable healthcare division. (4)

So come on NYT spend 5 mins getting the story straight instead of writing a lazy click bait headline.

(1) https://www.solveforx.com/

(2) https://www.engadget.com/2016/02/01/google-alphabet-q4-2015-...

(3) https://techcrunch.com/2013/08/22/google-ventures-puts-258m-...

(4) http://www.recode.net/2016/4/13/11586102/verily-alphabet-pro...

3 comments

> So come on NYT spend 5 mins getting the story straight instead of writing a lazy click bait headline.

Actually, NYT has syndicated an article originally written by a reporter of the Associated Press. It says so right at the top.

http://hosted2.ap.org/APDEFAULT/495d344a0d10421e9baa8ee77029...

> "Other Bets" includes Nest, Google Fiber, Google Ventures, and Verily among others(2)

The fact that most of those things aren't huge money losers undercuts your argument though. Nest is making money. Google Ventures is $300 million a year, Fiber invested $100 million in KC in 2013, meanwhile this segment was $3.6 billion in the red last year.

Yes, but they could* be taking write-downs on their investments in e.g. Nest.

*I haven't looked at their financial statements.

For anyone else not familiar with it, Tango looks to be phone-based AR that requires specific hardware: https://get.google.com/tango/